[Neurons] 2019 Neurons #41 PRESENTISM -- THE DIFFICULTY OF PAST THINKING

[Michael Hall]

From: L. Michael Hall

2019 Neurons #41

September 2, 2019


Cognitive Fallacies Continued

 

PRESENTISM

The Difficulty of Thinking about the Past

 

When it comes to the past, whether it's your own personal history, some
other person's history, or the history of an age- it is very, very difficult
to think clearly and intelligently.  There are several reasons for this.
Let's start with your own history and your cognitive awareness of that
history, what we call memory.

 

When it comes to memory, there are so many different kinds of memory; there
are also many different brain areas and functions responsible for the
different kinds.  There is short-term working memory and long-term memory.
There is autobiographical or narrative memory which is how we sustain a
stable sense of self across time.  There is semantic memory, procedural
memory, flashbulb memory, etc.  There is implicit and explicit memory.  Lots
of kinds of memory!

 

How does memory work?  Well, we know that it certainly does not work like
the memory of a computer.  Push "save" and the computer's memory encodes and
stores the code and when you retrieve it later by "opening" the file, what
you stored is what you get- high fidelity.  Not so with human memory!
First, what and how you remember depends on the code and the coding you use-
it is a construct of your perceptions, understandings, sensory-awareness,
beliefs, etc.  And then every time you retrieve the memory and refresh it,
you reconstruct it so that it is changed ever-so-subtly and unconsciously by
your current state of mind.  How about that!  What you are currently
thinking changes what you previously thought.

 

Precisely because remembering is re-constructing, there is no "pure" or
pristine memory.  We do not remember things so much as they were, but as we
are.  This also explains how memories can be changed and always is being
changed.  It explains how you construct false memories and how false facts
can fairly easily be imprinted into your memories.

 

Daniel Gilbert in Stumbling on Happiness (2005) described the power of
experience on memory. 

"There isn't a view from nowhere.  Once we have an experience, we are
thereafter unable to see the world a we did before.  Our innocence is lost
and we cannot go home again." (p. 57)

 

The same dynamics occur when we try to "remember" (understand, comprehend)
the past of individuals from previous ages or even an age.  Gilbert's book
focuses on one thing- why we are so bad at predicting our personal and
emotional futures.  He notes that it is a cognitive fallacy to view the past
via presentism. 

"Historians use the word presentism to describe the tendency to judge
historical figures by contemporary standards.  As much as we all despise
racism and sexism, these isms have only recently been considered moral
turpitudes, and thus condemning Thomas Jefferson for keeping slaves or
Sigmund Freud for patronizing women is a bit like arresting someone today
for having driven without a seat belt in 1923.  And yet, the temptation to
view the past through the lens of the present is nothing short of
overwhelming." (2005, pp. 161-2)

 

It is very, very difficult to take second perceptual position with another
person as you try to empathize and understand what the other is experiencing
on their terms and from their perceptive.  It is even more difficult to put
ourselves into the historical cultural frames of mind of a previous age and
seek to truly understand how people thought, reasoned, felt, perceived, etc.
The easiest thing, and the most fallacious thing, is to evaluate (judge)
them from our perspective- our values, our understandings, our
frames-of-mind, our frames of reference, etc.

 

Yet when innocence has been lost, you cannot go home. You can't even do that
with your own past (history).  Try to remember what and how you thought and
felt when you were five.  Or when you were twelve.  You can't!  And worse,
notice how easy it is to judge your past self for something stupid that you
said or did.  Yet how unfair to that past self to judge through today's
lens.  Since then you have learned a lot, experienced a lot, matured, grown
up, left home.  The innocence of that previous stage of life is gone.   And
you can't go back.

 

Where you are today-how you are thinking, feeling, perceiving, valuing,
evaluating, etc.- determines and governs how you re-construct past memories.
It contaminates what you remember.  It affects your memory of your own life
and of all those who came before you.

 

Regarding Thomas Jefferson in the reference above, today it is impossible
for us to put ourselves back into the cultural and social context of the
late 1700s.  Slavery had been going on for hundreds of years.  The slave
industry was running strong and only in the 1700s did the more enlightened
came to the conclusion that it was wrong and dehumanizing.  It took longer
for those in the industry to see it.  Both the ship-owners who transported
the slaves and the tribal chiefs who gathered their own people, jailed them,
and sold them had vested financial interests in that industry.  So it took
them much longer to accept that their industry would end. 

 

We didn't live in that world- in that cultural milieu.  And because we
didn't grow up in a culture in which that was accepted as normal, it is
nearly impossible today to even imagine that.  When asked why Truman didn't
try to escape his constructed world in the movie Truman, the director
(played by Ed Harris) said, "We all accept the world as it is given to us."
You and I do the same.  Living in culture is living within a
mental/emotional environment of which we are mostly unconscious.  I wonder
what are some of the cultural things which we accept today that might be
consider shocking and abhorrent in the future?  Presentism- the cognitive
fallacy that contaminates looking at the past because we use the lens of
today.  It prevents us from truly going back.

 

 


 

 

L. Michael Hall, Ph.D.

Executive Director, Neuro-Semantics

P.O. Box 8

Clifton CO. 81520 USA

www.neurosemantics.com   look for the special offer

 

Author of the stunning new history of NLP--- NLP Secrets.  

Investigative Journalism which has exposed what has been kept secrets for
decades. 

http://www.neurosemantics.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NLP-Secrets-2_sml2.
png

 

 

 

 

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://pairlist8.pair.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20190908/dd544851/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.png
Type: image/png
Size: 137551 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://pairlist8.pair.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20190908/dd544851/attachment-0001.png>