[Neurons] 2018 Neurons #13 INDOCTORATION OR EDUCATON?

[Michael Hall]

From: L. Michael Hall

2018 Neurons #13

March 12, 2018

Thinking is in Short Supply #8

 

INDOCTORATION OR EDUCATION?

 

There's lots of things that stop thinking, that is, things which prevent
people from thinking in the sense of learning and discovering.  I've
mentioned a number of these ways in this series on how thinking, real
thinking, is in short supply.  One of the primary ways that we humans stop
thinking is by indoctoration which is a substitute of real education.

 

To indoctorate is to take some idea (doctrine) whether a belief, a rule of
conduct, a policy, a framework of understanding, an assumption, etc. and get
someone to believe it and accept it so that they do not question it.  In the
dictionary it is also described as "to often repeat an idea or belief to
someone in order to persuade them to accept it."  "The act of
indoctrinating, or teaching or inculcating a doctrine, principle, or
ideology, especially one with a specific point of view."

 

When we indoctorate someone we seek to get them to unthinkingly and even
blindly accept an idea so that it is treated as an unquestioned given.  This
tends to be one of the functions of every "culture," whether it is the
family culture, business culture, or religious, ethnic, national, etc.
culture.  When everybody around us assumes and acts in a similar way, then
it is difficult to even think an opposite thought or to question it.  As a
cultural given, it is then easily accepted as "the way it is."

 

Education, however, is (or should be) completely different from this.
Education is defined as "the act or process of imparting or acquiring
general knowledge, developing the powers of reasoning and judgment, and
generally of preparing oneself or others intellectually for mature life."

 

Education, from the Latin word educare and from ducere "to lead," literally
refers to the act of leading out.  That is, you lead out of the person the
discovery which then enables it to be that persons.  It refers to enabling a
person to bring out or train out one's thinking, questioning, discovering,
etc. in the process of learning.  Going back to Socrates and Plato, the idea
in education is that there is within us the knowledge or at least the
capacity to know and to understand.  Education draws out this capacity
thereby enabling our ability for learning.  More important than the specific
content of what we learn is our increased ability to learn- to think, to
understand, to question, to explore, etc.

 

Given this, the least effective way to education is to lecture.  To tell
someone what to think shortcuts the learning, the thinking, and the
discovery process.  To lecture, tell, instruct, preach, etc. is
spoon-feeding people with the answers.  And as noted in Neurons #7, when we
get answers, we generally stop thinking.  Giving people answers will make
you feel good, even powerful, knowledgeable, and in-the-know, and the answer
will give people a short-term pleasure.  Yet in the long run it cheats them.
That's because it undermines their learning to use their mind and discover
for themselves.

 

This robs them from having to exercise their minds- they do not exert their
brains, they do not struggle to gain clarity or to focus.  Answers are to
the brain what junk-food is to the body.  It is sweet and delicious.  Like
jello, it is easy to swallow.  You don't have to chew.  But without the need
to chew, to tear apart, and to digest, you can't make it your own.  You
can't incorporate it into the very fabric of you.

 

Many people who think they are educated are actually only indoctrinated.
Content information has been pumped into them which they have learned and
over-learned so that they can recall it, quote it, and filter things through
it.  But they are not actually educated.  They can present and defend a
dogma, an ideology, but they cannot criticize it.  They cannot think about
it reflectively and they cannot bring critical thinking to it.  They are
"true believers" in that they are dogmatically inflexible and they cannot
look at their beliefs with humor.  Humor for them is sacriligious.

 

Recently when I presented some questions about what we were doing in Group
and Team Coaching, several begged for the answers.  I refused.  "Figure it
out," I said. "What do you think?  How will you find the answer?"  Later
when I was asked about it privately, I said was on strike against
spoon-feeding the answers.  I don't know if that led the person to doing
some personal reflecting, but at least that stopped the petitioning.

 

Even if you've been indoctorated, even by good stuff, nothing stop you from
getting an education.  Engage in some critical thinking- use the Meta-Model
to question the assumptions you've been operating from, check the language
your ideas are coded in, and examine the facts that you've been using as
evidence.  Step back and look at the kind and quality of thinking that
you've been doing.  It's never too late to begin getting a true education.
Adopt the attitude that Mark Twain took; he said that he "never let his
schooling get in the way of his education."

 

 

 

Neuro-Semantic News

.        It's time to sign up for NSTT and get your Trainers' Training this
year.  Come to Colorful Colorado July 1-15 for the event.  Write for
information: meta at acsol.net 

 

 

 

L. Michael Hall, Ph.D., Executive Director 

Neuro-Semantics 

P.O. Box 8

Clifton, CO. 81520 USA                             

               1 970-523-7877 

                    Dr. Hall's email:
<mailto:meta at acsol.net\hich\af31506\dbch\af31505\loch\f31506> meta at acsol.net


    ISNS new logo

    

 

Dr. L. Michael Hall writes a post on "Neurons" each Monday.  For a free
subscription, sign up on www.neurosemantics.com.   On that website you can
click on Meta-Coaching for detailed information and training schedule.   To
find a Meta-Coach see  <http://www.metacoachfoundation.org>
www.metacoachfoundation.org.   For Neuro-Semantic Publications --- clink
Products, there is also a catalog of books that you can download.   

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://pairlist8.pair.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20180311/c88a1af0/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 10627 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://pairlist8.pair.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20180311/c88a1af0/attachment-0001.jpg>