[Neurons] 2014 "Neurons" Meta Reflections #49

Mon Dec 8 10:10:20 EST 2014

From: L. Michael Hall

Meta Reflections 2014 #49

Dec. 8, 2014

CRTICAL THINKING ABOUT

mBRAINING

An NLP Trainer of considerable skill in presentation elegance and NLP
knowledge is Marvin Oka of Melbourne Australia.  I originally met Marvin at
the 1997 Visionary Leadership Conference in Santa Cruz California and
quickly came to appreciate his skills as a presenter and him as a person.
Fast forward 17 years and last week at the London NLP Conference I had the
privilege of hearing him again.  There he presented a seminar that he calls
mBraining.  I heard the first 2 ½ hours of that seminar and then left to
participate in the NLP Leadership Summit.

The presentation was very good even though it was not interactive, not a
single question was allowed during that time.   Otherwise I would have
raised some questions.   The “m” in mBraining stands for multiple brains.
This is central and based on the assumption that we have three brains.  From
that Marvin and an associate have designed several integration techniques
for aligning these three brains.  He calls this mBit which stands for
Multiple Brain Integration Techniques.

Marvin began by attempting to convince the audience of his basic premise,
namely, that “we have three brains.”  To do this, he used colorful and
fascinating images in his PowerPoint presentation of the brain— of neurons,
of neuro-pathways, etc.  Very impressive!  He then put up a quote from a
1912 book where the author called the “heart” a brain.”  Okkkaaaay.  He then
defined “the brain” as a complex neural network, which really isn’t a
definition, but a description of its composition.  Then lo and behold, with
that “definition” sudden the heart is declared to be a brain!  He drew his
conclusion with a dramatic flare: “That means that the heart is a ‘brain!’
Because it is a network of neurons, it is able to receive input messages
from the rest of the body and to send out output messages.”  Marvin noted
that it also has the ability to “remember,” and therefore it is another
“brain.”

To further his argument, he quoted some antidotal stories about a man who
had a heart transplant and who later experienced “strange thoughts and
feelings,” only then to discover that his donor was a woman.  “Wow!  Was her
heart— as a ‘brain’ communicating her thoughts and emotions to him?”  Taking
this to the next level, Marvin then asserted that the “gut,” the digestive
system, because it also is “a complex neural network” and because it is
comprised of millions of neurons, it must also be a “brain.” It receives
input messages and sends out messages.

Now if this line of thinking makes sense to you, that’s okay.  You are
probably simply going with it to see where these thoughts take you.  That’s
a sympathetic way to listen to someone and says you are seeking to
understand the person’s concept and/or conclusions.  That’s what I did as I
first listened.  When that was complete, I then began thinking through this
line of thinking.  As I then began using the critical thinking questions of
the Meta-Model, I began to sense all sorts of problems about this.  Do you?
You might want to stop here and check it out.  If there is something wrong
with that way of thinking, what is it?  What are the problems that appear to
you about all of this?

The first and primary thing for me was the label of “heart.”  In NLP we know
that words are just labels, a way of mentally mapping something.  So just
using a word or label doesn’t necessarily make it so.  So consider the label
and metaphor of “brain.”  Yes I know that we in the West, and especially
English speakers, use the word “heart” for emotions.  And on Valentines day
we go crazy with “heart” as a synonym of emotion, caring, and love.  But
that is a cultural fact which arose in Europe and England a few centuries
ago.  Today western English speakers think of this as an universal fact.
But it is not.  Back in biblical times, for example, the Hebraic way of
portraying the heart was completely different: “As a man thinks in his
heart, so is he.” (Proverbs 23:7).  In the Bible “heart” never did service
for “emotion,” it was the cognitive center.  The emotion center was the
“bowls,” the liver, the kidney, the lower stomach.  The head served as the
“self” or “self-esteem” center— to turn away one’s face is to shame someone,
to be honored is to have one’s head lifted up.  (I have a whole chapter on
this in the book, Emotions: Sometimes I Have Them/ Sometimes They Have Me.)

Then there’s that thing about heart transplants and picking up on another
person’s thoughts and emotions.  So if the muscle that we call “the heart,”
which pumps blood which carries oxygen and nutriments to every cell of the
body and transports toxins away from the cells, is the place of “the
emotional heart,” then what happens when a person gets a plastic heart
rather than a heart transplant?  Does that mean that the person will not
have an “emotional heart?”  Will that person not feel emotions any longer?
We know that’s not the case.  Nor is “the heart” the place where our
emotions are primarily created.  Instead they are created in parts of the
brain: in the limbic system, in the thalamus, the amygadala, the
hypothalamus which excites the sympathetic nervous system, etc.

Nor does the heart process cognitive knowledge.  It processes information
about pumping more blood, less blood.  Nor does the digestive system process
cognitive information.  The information it deals with has to do with
breaking down food for nourishment and rejecting what does not serve the
body.  With most of the immune system cells there, it is a first-line
defense sorting out “me” and “not me.”

Three “brains” is an interesting metaphor, yet that is all it is–a metaphor.
We do not literally or actually have three (or more) “brains.”  Is there
“intelligence” in our body and its functions?  Yes, of course.  But what
intelligence?  And what kind of intelligence?  That’s the question.  We have
to be careful about the entailments when we use a metaphor like “brain” or
“intelligence.”  Sure the body “knows” things– all kinds of things— as its
“intelligences” facilitate self-healing and automatic functioning.  While a
person may accommodatively use “brain” as a metaphor about heart or gut, we
cannot expect the label “brain” to carry with it all of the other
metaphorical connotations. 

Later I heard from several people at the Conference that they liked many of
the techniques that came out of this work.  They said they were processes
for alignment and congruency, and of course, one cannot go wrong with that.
But “three brains?”  When I meta-model it for precision, and challenge the
metaphor for its references, the kind of intelligence in the heart and
digestive system is hardly a “brain” in the way we think of brain. Being
like a “brain” in one aspect doesn’t make it a brain.

L. Michael Hall, Ph.D.

                Neuro-Semantics Executive Director 

                Neuro-Semantics International

P.O. Box 8

Clifton, CO. 81520 USA                             

                1 970-523-7877 

                Dr. Hall's email:
<mailto:meta at acsol.net\hich\af31506\dbch\af31505\loch\f31506> meta at acsol.net

What is Neuro-Semantic NLP?

Neurons:  Get your free subscription to the weekly International \Post on
Neuro-Semantics by Dr. L. Michael Hall. Subscribe at:
wwww.neurosemantics.com 

    Solutions:  Sign up for the Neuro-Semantic Newsletter --- wwww.
<http://neurosemantics.com/newsletter> neurosemantics.com/newsletter. 

 This is a monthly newsletter for anyone new to Neuro-Semantics.  Femke
Stuut, Editor.

Coaching: For world-class Coach Training — The Meta-Coaching System:
www.meta-coaching.org and \
<http://www.metacoachfo/hich/a/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506%20f3150
6/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506%20undation.org/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31
506/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506> www.metacoachfoundation.org.
Meta-Coach Reflections sent every Wednesday to the group of Licensed
Meta-Coaches.

Self-Actualization: Neuro-Semantics launched the New Human Potential
Movement in 2007, for information about this, see
<http://www.self-actualizing.org/> www.self-actualizing.org  

NSP --- Neuro-Semantic Publications: Order books from Neuro-Semantic
website,  <http://www.neurosemantics.com> www.neurosemantics.com  click on
Products and Services and then the Catalogue of books.  Order via paypal.  

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://pairlist8.pair.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20141208/9678340b/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.png
Type: image/png
Size: 81558 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://pairlist8.pair.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20141208/9678340b/attachment-0001.png>