[Neurons] 2010 Meta Reflections #46

[L. Michael Hall]

From: L. Michael Hall

Meta Reflections 2010 – #46

Sept. 20, 2010

History of NLP Series #10

 

 

THE LAWSUIT

THAT ALMOST KILLED NLP

 

In the 1990s a blow was delivered to the field of NLP that nearly destroyed
the field in the United States.  Elsewhere in the world NLP kept growing and
thriving, but not in the United States and the effect has continued to this
day.  What happened is a very sad chapter in the history of NLP. 

 

It began in July of 1996 when Richard Bandler filed a $90,000,000 lawsuit as
a civil action against John Grinder, Carmen Bostic St. Clair, Christina
Hall, Steve and Connirae Andreas, and Lara Ewing and 200 John and Jane Does.
In that lawsuit Bandler claimed exclusive ownership of the Society of NLP.
Copies of the lawsuit are still available on various websites.

 

The first effected me in early 1997.  Having just completed another NLP
Practitioner Course with 20 people, I sent a check for $4,000 ($200 per
participant was the arrangement) and the certificates to the “First
Institute of NLP” in San Francisco for Richard Bandler to sign.  As a NLP
trainer, this was the arrangement that I had been following for seven years,
but this time Brahm von Huene returned the check and certificates and sent a
new contract for me to sign.

 

In the contract, I crossed out the section that said that anything I
developed based on NLP would be considered the intellectual property of
Bander and the section that if he decided to sue me, I would assume
responsibility for all legal bills.  Of course, I would not sign that!  I
initialed both places, and then sent the money, certificates and the
contract back.  Shortly thereafter all was returned again with the statement
that I was no longer a NLP trainer under the Society of NLP.

 

By June of 1997 the lawsuit had become big news in the field of NLP, and so
when Robert Dilts sponsored the Visionary Leadership conference in Santa
Cruz California, word about the lawsuit was the central thing that everybody
was talking about.  There were over 200 NLP Trainers who had gathered from
all around the world for this conference.

 

A day or two later, Judith DeLozier announced in the conference that John
Grinder had showed up—but he would not come into the meeting place where we
were all gathered.  I think it was Judith DeLozier who announced that John
would meet with anyone who wanted to talk to him about the lawsuit “out on
the grass” in front of the venue.  So many of us met with John and listened
to what he told us about the lawsuit.  He was there also to raise money for
his legal defense.

The very next day, Richard Bandler sent his lawyer (!) who also came and
meet with anyone who wanted to talk to him “out on the grass.”  And again,
many of us when out to talk to him.  Wyatt Woodsmall and I stood next to
each other, and when there was a moment for some questions, I had the
contract that had been returned to me, so I held it forth and asked
Richard’s lawyer about it.  But it was a futile attempt for any reasoning.

 

The contract that I signed, sent back with the two sections crossed out,
began with these words which tells a lot about what all the ruckus was
about:

“The Licensor owns throughout the World all rights, title, and interest in
and to the intellectual property known as Neuro-Linguistic Programming...”

 

So there was no question that Bandler’s 1996 lawsuit was an attempt to take
over and totally control the field of NLP.  And from the perspective of
1996, 1997, etc. it seemed very likely that that might happen.  It seemed
that he had the trademark.  That’s why Dr. Bob Bodenhamer and myself decided
that we would trademark and register “Neuro-Semantics.”  Our thinking was
that if Bandler did win the lawsuit, and forbid us from training NLP, we
would still be able to train under the banner of Neuro-Semantics and that
also explained why we set forth a vision of being more professional, more
collaborative, more “applying to self,” etc.

 

During this time John Grinder put out a Statement about the lawsuit, Robert
Dilts wrote a paper on Trademarks, and NLP Connection, and many other
journals kept the field informed about what was going on.  Steve Andreas
asked me if I would be available and willing to make a deposition about NLP
and be disposed by Bandler’s lawyer.  I was to provide “some substantial
documentation of the many sources that Bandler drew upon in the development
of NLP— what he got from Bateson, from Perls, Satir, Chomsky, etc.”  I had
been writing about the intellectual history of NLP for years, and I readily
agreed to provide that.  I told Steve that I was highly disappointed in
Bandler, that Steve had done more to put Bandler on the map than anyone, and
that yes, of course, I would testify on his behalf.

 


>From 1996 to 2000 (when the lawsuit was settled), hundreds of people in the

United States, scared of Richard and fearful of being added to the lawsuit
as one of the “John Does” began divesting themselves of NLP— they stopped
referring to what they did as “NLP” and those running training centers
either closed shop or changed their names.  By the end, there were but a
dozen centers left (if that) and even today, there’s very few Centers left,
no journals, no magazines, and no associations of NLP in the US.

 

What happened?  Chris Hall (no relation to me) explained in NLP World (July
2001): 

“The Court’s rulings have made it clear that Bandler’s claim to exclusive
and sole ownership of the Society and the intellectual property rights
associated with NLP have been false and unlawful.” (p. 17)

 

Christina Hall was one of my trainers when I learned NLP.  I recorded some
of her presentations and referred to her in my first two books on NLP: The
Spirit of NLP (1989; 1996) and Becoming More Ferocious as a Presenter
(1990).  She was in a special internship with Richard when I first met her
in 1989 and the president of “The Society of NLP.”  And given that she was
the representative leader of the “Bandler Group” who owned the trademark,
“Society of NLP,” when the trial was all over, she won the judgment over
Bandler and was awarded some $600,000.  I doubt she will ever receive any of
that because Bandler moved to Ireland!  It turned out that Richard Bandler
did not have the trademark for “NLP”—no one did.  And with that NLP was
declared in public domain.  (A similar thing happened in the UK, as Bandler
was convicted of receiving the trademark of NLP by fraud and fined 175,000
pounds.)

 

“The Bandler Group” was the group who in 1983 purchased the trademark of
“The Society of NLP” after  Liquidation of NOT Ltd. (Bandler’s original
company) went bankrupt. This group was named “the Bandler group” and was
comprised of Christina Hall, Max Steinback, M.D., Karen MacDonald, Ed and
Maryann Reese, Joseph and Linda Sommers-Yeager, and Richard Morales.

 

The trial lasted nine days and ended on Thursday, Feb. 10, 2000.  Chris Hall
tells about the testimony against Bandler and those who testified in the
court of Judge Yonts in Feb 2000.  This included Dr. Max Steinback, John
Grinder, Karen MacDonald (widow of Will MacDonald), and Christina Hall.

 

 

References:     

Andreas, Steve (1999).  Personal communications.

 

Hall, Chris.  (2001).  NLP World (Vol. 8, No. 2, July 2001).  In The Matter
of ...  Summary of the Bandler Lawsuit. pp. 15-24.

 

NLP Connections: June 10, 2010.  Volume XI, No. 2 and 3.  Phoenix, Arizona. 

 

 

 

 

Training News

Avignon France --- Oct. 1-3 --- Unleashing Leadership!

Gilles Roy Avignon, France, gilles.roy2 at wanadoo.fr
<mailto:gilles.roy2 at wanadoo.fr%0bwww.coaching-pnl.com> 
www.coaching-pnl.com
Formation Evolution et Synergie  (NLP Training Center)
3 Avenue de la Synagogue
84000 Avignon France

Tél 06 13 09 19 21 ou 04 90 16 04 16

 

 

October 7– 14

Coaching Mastery — Module III of Meta-Coaching

Where:            Stockholm, Sweden

Contact:           Sara Lee — sara.m.lee at gmail.com              Niklas
Daver,  <mailto:niklas.daver at gmail.com> niklas.daver at gmail.com  

                        and Helene Nordgen 

            

In November 2010 — Nov. 15– 16

 

What:                          Unleashing Potentials

When:                          November 15– 16, 2010

Where:                        Bedfordshire, England

Time:                           9:00 am — 6:00 pm 

 

Organizers:                 Joe and Melody Cheal [
<mailto:joe.cheal at gwiztraining.com> joe.cheal at gwiztraining.com] 

Contact Info.:             email:  <mailto:info at gwiztraining.com>
info at gwiztraining.com 

                                    phone: 01767 640956

                                       The GWiz Learning Partnership

 

 

In November 2010 — Nov. 19-21 

 

What                           Unleashing Vitality

When:                          November 19– 21

Where                         City Hotel — North Central Italy

                                    I-40026 Imola BO

Airport                         Bologna (http://foxyurl.com/4qg) 25 miles
away),

                                                or Forlì (
<http://foxyurl.com/4qf> http://foxyurl.com/4qf) 27 miles away)

Time:                           9 am to 6 pm.

Contact details            Nicola Riva and Lucia Giovannini

                                    mobile: +39 348 5600507

 <mailto:nicola at blessyou.it> nicola at blessyou.it





 

 

 

L.  Michael Hall, Ph.D.

Executive Director, International Society of Neuro-Semantics

P.O. Box 8

Clifton, CO.  81520 USA

1 970-523-7877

     www.neurosemantics.com 

       <http://www.self-actualizing.org/> www.self-actualizing.org

       <http://www.meta-coaching.org/> www.meta-coaching.org

       www.meta-coachfoundation.org  

       <http://www.ns-video.com/> www.ns-video.com 

 

For a free subscription to Neurons--- the Internatioinal  egroup of
Neuro-Semantics, go to the front page of  <http://www.neurosemantics.com/>
www.neurosemantics.com.   You can  subscribe and unsubscribe there.   Meta
Reflection articles by Dr. Hall are sent out every Monday (Colorado time).
Trainers' Reflections are on Tuesdays and Meta-Coach Reflections on
Wednesdays.   Contact Dr. Hall at  meta at acsol.net  

 

 

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://eight.pairlist.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20100920/2b09666c/attachment.html>